• HAKANIN.com

    for everything video games, technology, and offbeat news.

J-Train Blog: Some After Thoughts…

Paul’s Note: The following article was posted on 8/16. For the original article in Traditional Chinese, click HERE.

I have been terribly busy these past couple days, kinda short handed at work, so I haven’t had much time to work on my blog. I read some stuff by Taiwanese media and the feedbacks of my readers, here are a couple thoughts -

First of all, about Joe Torre’s comments to Wang. Torre wants Wang to go back to the basics, trust his pitches, I am sure people have read the stories.

Yet, some media seemed to interpret as that “Torre wants Wang to do this, Guidry wants Wang to do that, who should Chien-Ming Wang listen to?” I think they misunderstood the point.

It is true that Gator taught him breaking balls but he never told Wang “not to throw his fastballs.”

Torre reminded Wang not to “forget the basics,” don’t throw too many breaking balls, and return to his old style of challenging the strikezone. He never once said “don’t throw breaking balls”;

I don’t even think their points are conflicting, in fact, I think they are talking about the same thing.

Chien-Ming Wang’s strikeout rate has increased, but he also started to want to strikeout batters by painting the corners; and after the game in Toronto, he started worry about getting hit. Unfortunately he does not yet possess good enough of command, so if he doesn’t make a good pitch, or the home plate umpire has a cheap strikezone, then that is bad news for Wang.

“Don’t fall in love with breaking balls,” not only did Torre once said it, but also can be viewed as a rule of thumb. Only Taiwanese people would blindly go after the “rainbow breaking balls,” as if knowing more kinds of breaking balls the better, and ask Wang the same old question everyday “did you learn any new pitch?” A pitcher should still build his/her foundation on the fastball. 95 MPH, 88, 85, whatever, you just have to throw it. This is why we often talk about “establishing the fastball” or “controlling the plate.”

Torre did not prohibit Wang from pitching breaking balls, what he wants is attitude — he does not want to see Wang cutting corners, afraid to get hit; same with Guidry, and that is why he would say things like “just throw the damn ball.” Just go with it, don’t be afraid. Even if Wang mastered the sliders taught by Guidry, but if he can’t attack the strike zone, Gator will still be upset.

It is kind of funny how whenever Wang does not perform as well, many so-called “experts” in Taiwan start talking about Wang’s sinkers, how they are not as sharp as before, or lack of movements at the end; yet on the other hand, you have never hear Torre or Guidry saying similar things when criticizing Wang. How about American media?

Perhaps I don’t read enough, but I don’t have any recollection of such criticism.

The coaches still insist that “there is nothing wrong with his stuff,” or Torre even said it once “sometimes Wang has so much movement on his sinkers, he has a hard time controlling it,” and Gator has also brought up similar points.

Still, our “experts” in Taiwan insist that Wang’s sinkers has lost its power?

It is true that he has some controlling issue, and it is also true that base runners often affect his focus, but that is why you practice, and work on it. They simulate situations like this in bullpen sessions, so if Wang still has problems dealing with it, that’s his own obstacle, whether its mental or whatever.

I don’t want to claim I am someone close to Chien-Ming Wang, or a friend or anything. I am just someone that has covered him for the past 3 years from a close distance. I honestly don’t think that he is influenced by fame, or feeling the pressure as the “Light of Taiwan”; don’t get me wrong, I don’t mean that he doesn’t have a sense of honor or anything, my point is that –

It is just a slump.

When Jeter went through 26 ABs without a hit, or 0 for 32, that was a slump, no one said Jeter is feeling the pressure because of his fame; or when Matsui does not perform as well, we hardly hear people say he is under too much pressure to be the “Light of Japan.”

Slumps are slumps. Whether it’s caused by physical or mental reasons. I believe that for Taiwanese fans, we can support Wang, but at the same time, not to over analyze.

I wrote a piece back in spring training about “Wang doesn’t have a good change-up,” and someone responded to me that “you don’t know shit.”Yea, there are many things I don’t understand, but why can’t we fans accept the fact that “Chien-Ming Wang is human, too. He has flaws.” If watching baseball can go so far, life is pretty tough as well.

My job is to observe and report. I am no expert or color commentator, but I can record some conversation and interaction of coaches and players, and write an article; or sharing some stories or observations I saw first hand with the rest of you. The truth is that, I love baseball, and I enjoy watching the games whether Wang does well or not. I simply enjoy this game.

J-Train writes for the Word Journal, one of the bigger Mandarin news paper in North America, in NYC. He spends most of his time covering Asian athletes, with focus on Chien-Ming Wang and the New York Yankees. He recently became the first Taiwanese baseball writer to join the Baseball Writers’ Association of America (BBWAA). For more of his articles, you may go to The J-Train Blog (it’s in Traditional Chinese), or click HERE for my translated ones. For those English speaking fans, HAKANIN.com will continue to provide the translated version of his articles, so stay tuned!

Popularity: 38% [?]

If you liked this post, subscribe to HAKANIN's RSS feed.

WidgetBucks - Trend Watch - WidgetBucks.com

Filed under: Chien-Ming Wang, Joseph Liao, MLB, New York Yankees, Sports, Taiwan, The J-Train Blog

8 Responses to “J-Train Blog: Some After Thoughts…”

  1. No one says Matsui, or Matsuzaka or Ichiro, whoever, is under too much pressure because he’s not the only Japanese player in the big leagues. Wang, too, is not the only Taiwanese in MLB, but he’s the only one who has established a secure standpoint as a starter. He’s always been the focal point even when Tsao and Kuo of the Dodgers were activated.

    Sure everybody has a slump. But a slump doesn’t necessarily come without reasons. Torre and Guidry already made it clear that Wang put too much pressure on himself, didn’t they.

    As to the Jeter part… I think it’s out of question. Totally different cases here.

  2. Well, since I just translate, I didn’t put any opinion in the article =)

    but here is what I think J-Train meant to say when he brought up the name of Matsui. Yes he is not the only Japanese player in the league, so to use the “Light of Japan” analogy might not have been accurate. But the focus here is “National pride.” The pride in representing his country. Matsui was under enormous pressure and was heavily criticized when he chose not to participate in WBC. So the pressure to perform is still there, not only for Japan but also for the fans in NY. The point is that we hardly hear Japanese media trying to justify or criticize by saying Matsui’s under performing because of Japan, it’s just a slump.

    As far as the Jeter comparison goes, I guess J-Train was trying to find an example out of a famous player and the reaction of media/experts/fans, other than that, it might be a stretch too hehe.

  3. Yap I know you’re not the author. Just that too many people are on the J-train, I prefer to come here talking to a Hakanin. :)
    And yes, the theory of “national pride” does make sense to me, especially when I recall there’s also an Igawa in the Yankees.

    Then here comes another question: why so many people defend Wang with that pressure theory? I think Peter Abraham did so too. Weird.

  4. Hey Nakao Eki,

    my point there was, I’ve known Wang for 3 yrs. And I just don’t think he’s the type that thinks “I must do it for my country, those people back home are watching me”.

    And that’s not a knock on him. I mean, there’s no need to think that way.

    Peter Abraham is a good friend, but I have to disagree with him on this one. Focal point of the nation? Sure. But feeling pressure because of that? I don’t think so. That’s not Wang.

    However, it’s true that he’s putting pressure on himself. Torre and Gator are right about that. Though he doesn’t look like one, Wang’s a very competitive person. He simply hates to lose. He’s been very inconsistent lately, including that terrible start at Toronto. So he kinda lost confidence, and he’s been trying too hard to get out of the slump.

    So basically, the point I was trying make is, no, he doesn’t care about those “national pride” kinda stuff. But he does want to win, real bad.

  5. Thanks J-Train. Didn’t expect to see you here. :)
    I also don’t think Wang is that “I must do it for my country” type. Yet I’m wondering… “feeling pressure from being the focal point of the nation” and “being competitive” might be very similar, if not the same. Being the “pride of Taiwan” means a lot of people watching. And being a competitive person, it must have made him extremely uncomfortable to find himself not performing well in front of so many people. Hm, is that a sophistry? Ha! Forget it. I’ve got your idea. Thanks again for the explanation.

    One more thing: I think it’s quite obvious that Wang is very competitive. That he rarely shows his emotion on the field tells everything– so competitive that he doesn’t even want people to know he cares that much. Interesting personality. :D

  6. Nakao Eki,

    You know what, I think you’re right. I see what you were trying to say. Thanks.

    And yes, we all know Wang is competitive. I guess the reason why I said he doesn’t look like one, is because that he’s so soft spoken and polite off the court. Players, coaching staffs, Peter Abraham, me, and some other media people make fun of him all the time. It’s like I’m talking to just a regular guy, not “light of the Taiwan”.

  7. Hey J, nice to see you stopping by, hope I haven’t ruined any of your articles~

    And yeah, I think we all agree on the fact that the slump didn’t exactly occur with the whole “Light of Taiwan” nonsense. The point is Taiwanese media and their so-called “experts” making up excuses/reasons to cover Wang’s slump because 1) Part of them don’t want to believe Wang can simply “slump” because no true Aces slump, right? and 2) By making up reasons for Wang’s inconsistency, they “sound” like experts and get airtime, woohoo!

    Somebody needs to unplug their mics.

  8. Cannot agree more! Particularly the unplugging their mics part!

Leave a Reply